Bella Neuspiel Is Just Trying Not to Panic
On The Body, Neuspiel plays the girl trying to keep everyone calm. Off-screen, she’d probably be the first one freaking out.

Bella Neuspiel wants to be good at watching horror. She really does. She’s even attempted what she jokingly calls “exposure therapy,” working her way through scary movies in the hope that eventually they might stop being quite so scary. So far, progress has been limited. “I watch it all through my fingers,” she tells A Shot. “And I plug my ears too, and then you’re really not watching it at all.”
Once, she took someone on a date to see Longlegs, apparently imagining herself casually pulling up with the tickets and drinks. Instead, she spent most of the film curled into a ball, screaming.
“I was acting like a freaking fool.”
jacket. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
top. madalina caminschi (@madalinacaminschiofficial
pants. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shoes. rachel thorson (@rachelthorson) and jaiin kang (@jaiinkang)
belt. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
It makes Neuspiel’s role in Netflix’s The Body especially funny. Created by Quinn Shephard, the darkly comic teen thriller follows the girls of an elite Catholic school as a dance-team initiation spirals into something far stranger, setting off visions, paranoia and a wave of collective hysteria. The Canadian actress plays Katie, one of the Lions at the center of it all — and often the girl standing somewhere near the chaos wondering what, exactly, everyone is losing their minds over. Sarcastic, laid-back and very much unserious, she functions almost like an audience surrogate, poking holes in the hysteria while trying not to reveal that she might be a little more frightened than she lets on.
Neuspiel, by her own admission, would be less useful. “I’m super skittish. I’m so scared of everything,” she says. If someone in the group suggested they had seen something supernatural, she knows exactly what would happen: “I would be like, ‘Guys, don’t fuck around. I’m scared.’” Katie might try to stop the panic; Neuspiel suspects she would make it worse.
That contradiction feels fitting for a series built on them. The Body moves between horror and comedy, Catholic guilt and teenage horniness, collective hysteria and the very ordinary absurdity of being a girl among other girls. For Neuspiel, though, the initial attraction was much simpler: it actually made her laugh. “I’m such a big comedy person,” she shares. “The jokes are so witty, and the characters are all so funny in different ways.” Then she kept reading. There was the queer representation, the 2000s setting, the music already written into the script. “I was just like, damn, it’s going to be a blast.”
She was right — although “a blast” would eventually involve brutal dance rehearsals, Epsom salt baths, improvised confessions, sleepovers, lost phones, mass hysteria and a cast of young actors figuring out one of their first major projects together.
jacket. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
top. madalina caminschi (@madalinacaminschiofficial
pants. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shoes. rachel thorson (@rachelthorson) and jaiin kang (@jaiinkang)
belt. boy london america (@boylondonamerica) photographer. xinger xanger (@xingerxanger)
jacket. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
top. madalina caminschi (@madalinacaminschiofficial
pants. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shoes. rachel thorson (@rachelthorson) and jaiin kang (@jaiinkang)
belt. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
Katie had initially been described to Neuspiel as sarcastic and laid-back, qualities she recognised enough of herself in to think, “Yeah, this could be me.” As filming went on, that overlap became increasingly literal. Neuspiel began feeding more of herself into the character, and Shephard and director Gina Gammell encouraged her to keep going.
Even Katie’s wardrobe shifted. An initially more feminine look gave way to something more tomboyish, closer to Neuspiel’s own style, but the bigger change came through comedy. Neuspiel was always improvising, throwing jokes into scenes and seeing what survived. At one point, she thanked Shephard and Gammell for making her the jokester of the group. Their response caught her off guard: “They were like, ‘You did that all on your own.’”
“I could shed a tear,” she remembers. “They let me joke so much.” Plenty of what she improvised was, by her own admission, far too ridiculous to ever make the final cut — sometimes not even compatible with the plot — but she was given the freedom to keep trying it.
That looseness seems crucial to Katie. Even within the Lions’ social hierarchy, Neuspiel doesn’t imagine Katie spending much time thinking about where she ranks. Her influence comes almost accidentally. The other girls listen to her precisely because she isn’t fighting to be listened to.
“She’s on her own vibe,” Neuspiel notes. “I think she thinks of herself among the Lions as the person who’s going to chill everybody out” — the one trying to rein things in when the group begins spinning out.
The irony, of course, is that before Neuspiel and her castmates could convincingly become a teenage dance team slowly losing its collective mind, they first had to become something surprisingly close to a real one.
The process was brutal, to say the least. The cast went through an intensive dance boot camp before shooting, and Neuspiel laughs at the idea that anyone outside it could quite understand how serious it became. During the first week, they were taking Epsom salt baths just to deal with the pain. The choreography was packed with hair flips; soon, turning their heads left and right became a challenge. “The neck pain was unreal,” she deadpans.
At one point, word spread that the entire dance might be filmed in a single continuous shot. “I don’t know who sent around that rumor,” Neuspiel confesses, “but we were like, ‘We’re fucked.’”
At that point, simply making it through the choreography without collapsing felt difficult enough. Still, they rehearsed until movements that had initially seemed impossible became muscle memory. “Ryan came in and gave us this choreography and we were like, ‘Fuck, this shit is so hard,’” she remembers.
“Then when we got it, we were like, ‘Whoa. If we can do this, we can do anything.’”
jacket. catholic guilt (@catholicguilt_clothing)
top. liaba (@liabayasir)
shorts. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
necklace. quality zeeman (@quality_zeeman)
The dreaded one-shot never happened, but somewhere in all those hours of rehearsal, something more useful did: the Lions stopped having to pretend they were a team.
“We all really were best friends,” Neuspiel says. They would finish shooting and then, somehow, choose to spend their free time together too. There were sleepovers and nights out dancing, shopping trips and movie nights. Neuspiel, Kristina Bogic, Sara Boustany and Sofia Wylie developed a breakfast routine at Noni in Toronto, sitting outside with pastries. The cast trekked through the snow together to see Hamnet; Neuspiel slipped and fell on the way and remembers even that as “wonderful.” On another night, Emily lost her phone at a club and immediately decided Neuspiel was the person who would save the situation. There was one problem:
“I had just smoked an entire joint. I was like, well, fuck, what are we gonna do?”
jacket. catholic guilt (@catholicguilt_clothing)
top. liaba (@liabayasir)
shorts. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
necklace. quality zeeman (@quality_zeeman)
The closeness mattered because, for many of them, The Body was their first project on this scale. Instead of creating competition, Neuspiel remembers that newness flattening the usual hierarchy of a set. Nobody arrived acting as though they had already figured everything out. Neuspiel remembers a set where “everybody was genuinely so excited,” without much sense of hierarchy between them.
“We all were just so supportive of each other and working so hard.”
jacket. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
top. madalina caminschi (@madalinacaminschiofficial
pants. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shoes. rachel thorson (@rachelthorson) and jaiin kang (@jaiinkang)
belt. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
There is something fitting about that off-screen dynamic for a show so interested in what happens when girls operate as a collective. The Lions’ friendship can be cruel, absurd and combustible, but its intensity only works if you believe these girls are constantly reading and responding to one another. By the time the cameras rolled, Neuspiel and the others had spent weeks learning how to move together before they ever had to learn how to panic together.
And panic, Neuspiel explains, works much the same way. When she talks about filming the show’s descent into hysteria, she keeps returning to the idea of reaction: one girl believes something, another sees how frightened she is and becomes frightened herself, which gives the first girl even more reason to believe something is wrong. Fear travels around the group until nobody can quite identify where it started. “It’s a little bit the girlfriend mentality,” she considers, describing the instinct to become intensely invested in whatever your friends are feeling. “Every little thing makes it more real.”
For Neuspiel, the trick was not to manufacture hysteria individually, but to let the other actors continually change what was happening inside her. Someone escalates, you respond; your response gives somebody else something to escalate from. “We’re all throwing that kindling on that fire,” she says. “It’s just getting bigger.”
But getting there also meant resisting the temptation to anticipate what the audience already knows is coming. Because The Body announces early that something is off, it would have been easy for the performances to begin signaling darkness before the characters themselves had any reason to see it. “You can’t play the end before the beginning,” Neuspiel says.
The production filming roughly in sequence helped. In those early scenes at Devil’s House, the cast knew the story would spiral, but the Lions didn’t. So Neuspiel tried not to play the destination at all. “We were all super pumped,” she recalls.
“We were just like, ‘Let’s party. We’re at the house. We’re at Devil’s House. We’re having fun.’”
top. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shorts. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
boots. narcisz made (@narciszmade) photographer. xinger xanger (@xingerxanger)
top. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shorts. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
boots. narcisz made (@narciszmade)
By the time the story reaches its ritual and confession sequence, that carefree group energy has curdled into something much stranger. It is the scene Neuspiel immediately names when asked what stayed with her after filming — partly because of its intensity onscreen, and partly because making it felt almost completely different.
Shephard and Gammell encouraged the actors to bring in their own material, invent confessions and improvise. “We got to fuck around and play around so much,” Neuspiel shares. Between takes, people were laughing. Then the cameras would roll and the girls were crying, panicking and tearing into one another.
That dissonance became part of what Neuspiel loved about the day. What looks increasingly uncontrolled onscreen was, behind the camera, a space where she felt unusually protected. “Everybody held each other so well,” she reveals. “It was so clear how much we all loved each other and cared about how each other were doing.”
Even while filming it, she remembers sensing that the sequence might become one of the show’s defining moments. Watching the finished episode only confirmed it: the confessions piling up, the cuts moving between girls, comedy and cruelty repeatedly bleeding into each other. “We were like, whoa,” she recounts. “I think this is something kind of big that we just did.”
jacket. catholic guilt (@catholicguilt_clothing)
top. liaba (@liabayasir)
shorts. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
necklace. quality zeeman (@quality_zeeman)
That ability to make something horrifying and funny at once runs through The Body. The show can move from sex to religious fervour to an absurd joke without announcing that it has changed genres, and Neuspiel says the actors learned not to chase those tonal shifts. The stranger the material became, the more important it was to treat whatever was happening as completely real.
“The fear and the seriousness feed into the humor,” she explains. When a scene is funny, the characters being genuinely terrified can make it funnier. When it is frightening, refusing to perform the obvious markers of horror can make the unease sharper. “It’s about not overthinking it and just letting it feel real.”
That trust extended to the material itself. Shephard has spoken about the unusual freedom the series had to be as deranged, dumb and horny as its creators wanted, and Neuspiel says the cast could feel it on set. There was a recurring sense of testing the boundary — Can we actually do this? — only for something even stranger to appear in the next version.“That’s absolutely how we felt while it was happening,” she says.
“It did feel like Netflix was letting us do whatever we want.”
top. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shorts. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
boots. narcisz made (@narciszmade) photographer. xinger xanger (@xingerxanger)
top. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shorts. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
boots. narcisz made (@narciszmade)
For Neuspiel, that freedom is part of why the dialogue feels recognisable. The characters are allowed to be crude, horny, ridiculous and occasionally inappropriate without every rough edge being translated into the polished language of television teenagers. She credits Shephard and Gammell’s taste with keeping that messiness intact: the jokes feel like jokes these girls might actually make, and the uglier impulses aren’t immediately cleaned up for the audience.
The show’s 2000s DNA helped establish that language too. Mean Girls and Jennifer’s Body were already familiar territory for Neuspiel — “the freaking classics,” as she calls them — but preparing for The Body sent her deeper into the period.
“I got hit with some major anxiety and I was like, ‘I have to do all the research ever,’” she says. She watched as much 2000s material as she could, knowing the references informing the series. But The Body doesn’t feel interested in simply recreating the era. What it borrows from those films is something harder to pin down: the permission for teenage girls to be genuinely mean, strange, sexual, funny and difficult without reducing any one of those qualities to a lesson.
jacket. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
top. madalina caminschi (@madalinacaminschiofficial
pants. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shoes. rachel thorson (@rachelthorson) and jaiin kang (@jaiinkang)
belt. boy london america (@boylondonamerica) photographer. xinger xanger (@xingerxanger)
top. boy london america (@boylondonamerica)
shorts. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
boots. narcisz made (@narciszmade)
Katie would probably have fit right in. Asked where she would place her in the actual canon of 2000s teen movies, Neuspiel eventually lands somewhere between Mean Girls’ Janis Ian and a stoner comedy. The latter, it turns out, is not only where she sees Katie — it is also where she would quite like to go next.
“I’d love to be in a stoner comedy,” she says. More specifically: one about women. Neuspiel misses the loose, ridiculous comedies that seemed to proliferate in the 2000s and wants to see that energy return with women occupying the roles that historically belonged to men getting high and making terrible decisions.
Her other dream sits at almost the opposite end of the spectrum: “a female-directed, indie-feeling, grounded, queer-centered story” — something she can connect to and that feels important. Put together, the two ambitions make sense. Neuspiel is drawn to characters allowed to be funny, queer and imperfect without having to become symbols of anything.
It is also why she speaks so enthusiastically about The Body’s queer representation. For all the spectacle surrounding the girls — the visions, rituals, panic and increasingly unhinged behavior — their queerness is allowed to exist inside a much messier portrait of adolescence rather than becoming the sole reason the story considers them interesting.
And if Neuspiel gets her way, Katie’s story is nowhere near finished. Asked what she wants from a potential second season, she initially tries to approach the question seriously. She doesn’t think the supernatural events are necessarily real. What interests her is the possibility that the girls themselves have generated something powerful only because enough people have begun to believe them.
“Their emotions and these experiences they’re having are lowkey, like, power,” she says. The girls have already managed to alter an entire town’s understanding of what is happening. If the phenomenon is being created and sustained by them, she wonders, how much further could they push it?
Then the serious answer lasts approximately another minute.
“I want Elise and Anya to get together and be happy and run away to the hills.”
Katie should get “a love or two” and join them. Grace, meanwhile, should come back to life with wings, develop the ability to shoot fire from her hands, obliterate the town and move to Los Angeles to become a fashion designer.
It seems as good a plan as any.
jacket. catholic guilt (@catholicguilt_clothing)
top. liaba (@liabayasir)
shorts. natashia studio (@natashia.studio)
necklace. quality zeeman (@quality_zeeman)
Before she goes, A Shot asks Neuspiel its usual question: if she were a single shot in a film, what would we see? She thinks about it for a while. Not a close-up. Instead, the camera would sit at a medium distance — “just enough that you can be let into the love and the joy and the friendship that we can have together, but just far enough away that I’m comfortable.” It would look slightly upward at her, so she appears “huge and big and strong.” The sun would be behind her. Her hair, naturally, would be flaming red and blowing dramatically in the wind.
She immediately begins second-guessing the answer. “There’s got to be a better answer than that,” she laughs. There probably doesn’t. For someone who spends much of our conversation insisting she doesn’t know what she’s talking about before landing, eventually, on exactly what she means, it feels appropriately Neuspiel: funny, slightly self-deprecating, a little dramatic and sincere enough to work anyway.
- Photographer: Xinger Xanger — @xingerxanger
- Art Department: Hallie Gluk — @halliegluk
- Assistant: Alex Punch — @alexpunch1
- Makeup: Pablo Macias — @pablomaciasr
- Hair: Jay Birmingham — @jaybirmingham_
- Stylist: Jaiin Kang — @jaiinkang
- Stylist: Rachel Thorson — @rachelthorson

